Three Jews and Six Catholics Walked Into The Supreme Court
May 9, 2010 5 Comments
Interestingly, religion plays into Supreme Court nominations. Obama was considering two Jewish people for the Supreme Court nomination. Stevens is Protestant – and apparently the only current Protestant Supreme Court Justice. With Obama’s choice of Kagan, assuming she is confirmed, there will be no Protestant Justice. This is interesting in the United States, with the country’s White Anglo-Saxon Protestant background. Perhaps this is a step towards a more diverse country? I’m sure Obama will be attacked for that one by someone. Clearly diversity is bad. Oh wait…
Interestingly, one Rabbi stated “that possibly having no Protestant justice member on the court could be seen as a lack of diversity, but he also stressed that this has more to do with the court having six Catholic justices.” How ironic.
Kagan is said to have views that are in line with the Jewish community. That could prove to be good for the Jewish community. She is also said to be liberal, but fairly moderate. That should get her Republican support. I hope that she rules without political bias though, the same way I believe all Supreme Court Justices should. That may be a little utopian though.
The religious makeup of the Supreme Court has changed dramatically over time. In 1800, it looked like this:
And in 2000, before Stevens’ retirement, it looks like:
According to an author quoted by NPR, “religion is the third rail of Supreme Court politics. It’s not something that’s talked about in polite company”.
It will be interesting to see how this plays out in the Senate over the next few weeks and what the commentators have to say.